You're building a new thing. You want functionality X. A new specification for X that does everything you want has recently emerged. What do you do? Do you spit in your fists and go to work implementing all the previous attempts at achieving X?
I think you have your bias because you are using OTR, and I have mine because I'm not.
I can justify my bias like this: If we're trying to grow XMPP in general, and neat clients is an important part of that, then newcomers won't be attached to OTR, they'll take whatever is offered.
I think efforts on usability are better spent than efforts on implementing OTR.
@dogjaw @roka @clacke @dt @ayy No, It has a legitimate use, it's like the fediverse. what would be the point of GS if every instance was its own island?
@ayy @roka @dirb @dt @dogjaw Yes, the core of it is really identity. I didn't get it when Moxie was talking about it, but that really is it. The home server is also involved in boring technical details and things are synchronized and whatever, but the main point is I register an account somewhere and now I have access to all these offerings, and nobody is in charge of the catalog.
Sure, people run networks on IRC servers, but then there's only one namespace. If I don't like the central version in that IRC network of what a #britbong channel should be about, that's it.
I really don't get how we can be having this part of this conversation on a network that wouldn't exist without federation. I wouldn't know you existed. It enabled this.